10 Historical Lies Everyone Think To Be True
Misconceptions and historical inaccuracies can persist in popular understanding for various reasons, including myth, oversimplification, or the passage of time. Here are 10 historical misconceptions or "lies" that many people think to be true:
Columbus Discovered America:
Columbus, an Italian explorer sailing under the flag of Spain, embarked on his famous voyage in 1492 with the goal of finding a westward route to Asia. Instead, he reached the islands of the Caribbean, landing on one of the Bahamian islands on October 12, 1492. He then explored other islands in the Caribbean, including Cuba and Hispaniola (present-day Haiti and the Dominican Republic).
Columbus completed four voyages across the Atlantic Ocean between 1492 and 1504, exploring parts of Central and South America, but he never reached the mainland of North America. His voyages, however, opened the door for further exploration and eventual European colonization of the Americas.
While Columbus played a significant role in connecting the Old and New Worlds, it's essential to recognize the indigenous peoples who had long inhabited the Americas and the explorers who came before Columbus, such as the Vikings led by Leif Erikson, who are believed to have reached North America around the year 1000. Additionally, Columbus was not the first European to reach the Americas in the 15th century, as Norse explorers had likely arrived earlier.
The term "discovery" itself is controversial, as it implies that the Americas were unknown or undiscovered before Columbus, disregarding the rich cultures and civilizations that existed in the region. In modern discussions, there is a growing awareness of the need to acknowledge and respect the contributions of indigenous peoples and their histories.
Vikings Wore Horned Helmets:
The myth of the horned helmets can be traced back to artistic representations from the 19th century and earlier. Artists and costume designers of that time period may have incorporated horned helmets to create a more dramatic and exotic image of the Vikings. These depictions, however, do not reflect the historical reality of Viking attire.
Archaeological findings have revealed several well-preserved Viking helmets, and none of them have featured horns. Viking helmets were typically made of iron and had a conical or rounded shape to provide protection to the head. They often included a nose guard and cheek flaps for additional coverage. The design of these helmets was pragmatic, focused on functionality rather than elaborate ornamentation.
The idea of Vikings wearing horned helmets has persisted in popular culture, but it's crucial to recognize it as a historical inaccuracy. Vikings were skilled seafarers, traders, and warriors with a rich cultural heritage, but the image of horned helmets is a product of artistic embellishment rather than historical fact.
Napoleon Was Very Short:
Napoleon's height is recorded as approximately 5 feet 6 inches (1.68 meters) in French feet and inches of the time, which would be around 5 feet 2 inches (1.57 meters) in modern measurements. This was actually slightly taller than the average height for Frenchmen in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.
The misconception about Napoleon's height may have originated from confusion between French and English measurement systems, as well as from political caricatures that aimed to diminish his stature in a metaphorical sense. Over time, these depictions contributed to the popular belief that Napoleon was unusually short.
In reality, while Napoleon was not exceptionally tall, he was not abnormally short either, and his height should not be exaggerated as much as historical caricatures often suggest.
The Great Wall of China Is Visible from Space:
The myth likely originated from a misinterpretation
of statements made by early astronauts who could see city lights and other
features from space. The Great Wall, however, is not easily distinguishable
from orbit without the aid of specific equipment. In fact, many other
structures and features on Earth, such as highways and large airports, are also
challenging to spot from space without the help of specialized instruments.
In summary, while the Great Wall of China is an impressive structure, it is not readily visible to the naked eye from space as the myth suggests. The visibility of human-made structures from space largely depends on various factors, including size, color, and the observer's altitude and viewing conditions.
Marie Antoinette Said "Let Them Eat Cake":
Marie Antoinette, the Queen of France, was
born in 1755 and married King Louis XVI in 1770. By the time she became queen,
the saying was already in circulation. It's likely that the attribution to
Marie Antoinette was part of the larger narrative depicting her as out of touch
with the struggles of the French people.
While there is no evidence that she uttered this phrase, Marie Antoinette did face criticism for her extravagant lifestyle and perceived indifference to the hardships faced by the French population, contributing to the negative public perception of her during the turbulent times leading up to the French Revolution. The phrase itself may have been used to symbolize the perceived callousness of the French aristocracy towards the suffering of the common people.
The Salem Witches Were Burned at the Stake:
Contrary to popular belief, the method of
execution during the Salem witch trials was hanging, not burning at the stake.
Burning at the stake was a method more commonly associated with witch trials in
Europe during earlier periods, but it was not the chosen form of execution in
the American colonies.
The Salem witch trials were a dark chapter in American colonial history, marked by widespread fear, hysteria, and unjust persecution. The legal and social repercussions of these events have been examined and criticized over the years, and they serve as a cautionary tale about the dangers of mass hysteria and the importance of safeguarding justice and individual rights.
Betsy Ross Designed the American Flag:
The story suggests that Betsy Ross proposed
the use of five-pointed stars instead of six-pointed stars and showed how to
cut a five-pointed star in a single snip. She is said to have completed the
flag in 1776. However, there is limited direct evidence to support these
specific details.
The primary source for this story comes from
affidavits provided by Betsy Ross's descendants in the late 19th century, long
after the events were said to have occurred. Some historians argue that these
accounts may have been influenced by patriotic sentiments and a desire to
establish a unique and compelling origin story for the American flag.
While Betsy Ross was a skilled seamstress and
did make flags during the Revolutionary War, the exact details of her
involvement in the design of the first American flag remain uncertain. The
design of the flag is generally attributed to a committee of individuals,
including Francis Hopkinson, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, who
submitted a bill to the Continental Congress for his work on the flag's design.
In summary, the claim that Betsy Ross designed the first American flag is a legend with a historical basis that is challenging to verify conclusively. The design likely resulted from collaborative efforts, and the story has become a part of American folklore and patriotic tradition.
Nero Fiddled While Rome Burned:
The event to which the
phrase refers is the Great Fire of Rome in AD 64. Nero was the Roman Emperor at
the time. While there are historical accounts of Nero being in the vicinity of
Rome while the fire raged, there is no solid evidence to support the claim that
he played the fiddle or any musical instrument during the catastrophe.
The story may have
originated as a political or literary criticism against Nero, who faced public
disapproval for his perceived extravagance and behavior. Some historians
believe that Nero took advantage of the fire to clear space in the city for his
architectural projects, which further fueled negative perceptions of him.
It's important to approach historical anecdotes with caution, especially when they involve dramatic or symbolic elements. The phrase "Nero fiddled while Rome burned" has endured as a metaphor for leadership negligence or indifference, regardless of the actual events surrounding the Great Fire of Rome.
Benjamin Franklin Discovered Electricity with a Kite:
The story goes that in
1752, Benjamin Franklin conducted an experiment during a thunderstorm by flying
a kite with a key attached to its string. According to the legend, as the storm
approached, Franklin observed that the key started to emit sparks when he
touched it. This led him to conclude that lightning was a form of electrical
discharge.
While the experiment
is widely associated with Franklin, there is some debate among historians about
whether he actually conducted it exactly as described. Franklin did write about
electrical experiments in a letter to Peter Collinson in 1752, but the details
of the kite experiment are not fully documented by Franklin himself. The
account comes from a letter written by Joseph Priestley in 1767, many years
after the alleged event.
It's possible that
Franklin used a kite to study the effects of electricity in a storm, but the
exact details remain uncertain. Regardless of the specifics, Franklin's
contributions to the understanding of electricity were significant. He
conducted various experiments with electrical charges, invented the lightning
rod to protect buildings from lightning strikes, and contributed to the
development of the theory of positive and negative electrical charges.
While the kite experiment story may have some elements of myth, Benjamin Franklin's work laid the foundation for our understanding of electricity, and he remains a key figure in the history of science and technology.
Paul Revere's Ride Alone:
Revere,
along with William Dawes and Dr. Samuel Prescott, set out from Boston to
Lexington and Concord to alert the colonial militias and patriots that British
troops were marching to seize military supplies and arrest revolutionary
leaders. The trio's mission was to spread the alarm across the countryside.
Paul
Revere is the most well-known of the three riders, thanks in part to Henry
Wadsworth Longfellow's poem "Paul Revere's Ride," which was written
in 1861. The poem focuses on Revere's contribution and portrays him as the lone
hero racing through the night to warn the colonists.
In reality, Revere was briefly captured by British patrols, while Dawes and Prescott continued the ride. Dawes did not complete the full journey, and it was Dr. Samuel Prescott who successfully reached Concord to warn the militias. The collective efforts of these riders, along with other messengers and riders, contributed to the success of the alarm system that night.So, while Paul Revere played a significant role in the midnight ride, he was not alone, and the event was a collaborative effort involving multiple riders striving to spread the warning across Massachusetts.